Lesson 4 · Module 2
Conflict transformation and mediation
Learn to walk towards conflict: understand its types and elements, recognise your own attitudes, and design a community system for dialogue and support.
Facilitators play a crucial role in conflict transformation and mediation by guiding parties towards mutual understanding and sustainable resolutions. They need neutrality, strong communication skills, and the ability to manage group dynamics to ensure all voices are heard. Key competencies (some covered in this topic, some in other parts of the course, and some elsewhere) include active listening, reframing, summarising, and asking open-ended questions to clarify interests and uncover underlying needs (compassionate communication!).
Facilitators must also learn to be adept at setting ground rules, managing emotions, and using techniques like caucuses and problem-solving methods to de-escalate tensions and build trust. In mediation, facilitators help parties explore options and negotiate agreements without imposing solutions. In conflict transformation, they focus on empowering individuals, fostering recognition of others’ perspectives, and understanding underlying traumas, shadows and unresolved (sometimes intergenerational, personal or collective) issues. Their role is to support self-driven resolution, ensuring the process remains collaborative, respectful and outcome-oriented.
Understanding conflict
“Creating freedom, community and viable relationships has its price. It costs time and courage to learn how to sit in the fire of diversity.” — Arnold Mindell
Conflict is inseparable from life and diversity. Where there is homogeneity, there is less conflict and less tension, but there is also less movement and less life. Our challenge as human beings is to support and appreciate diversity (a key component of life’s evolution and vitality on this planet) while we learn to recognise the unity underlying the apparent diversity. That way we can live with our differences, perhaps with tension and difficulties, but without violence, aggression or (self-)destruction.
To truly welcome diversity, equity and inclusion in all parts of our lives, we need to become willing to walk towards conflict. Within conflict there are keys to unlock the power in our diversity, our connectedness, and what matters most to us.
But to walk towards conflict, to hear the truth, requires courage; and courage requires support. With enough support from one another, we can charge our batteries with the courage to listen to others with true curiosity, listening for the truth we need in order to update our relationships.
This means that the success and vibrancy of our community depend on developing a system for working with conflict and a system for providing support to each other. We will explore the latter in Module 3. For now, let’s look at how to set up a system for engaging with conflict.
The most important task is to change our attitude from avoiding conflicts to looking at them with interest and openness. This means stepping out of a “win or lose” attitude and moving towards a “win-win” perspective. Win-win solutions become possible once all the parties involved in a conflict have been heard and understood.
This might feel impossible for those who have had experiences of conflict that became scary and damaging. We may fear that engaging with conflict will cause more harm than good. It is important to acknowledge these fears and the good reasons for them, and then to move ahead and apply our experience to design a system that we believe will work better.
Ten steps to engage with conflict in community
- Create a culture based on trust and honesty.
- Learn to understand and respect your own emotions and those of other people.
- Design a system for supported dialogue among those who are involved in a conflict.
- When conflict arises, get support to understand how you are feeling and what matters most to you.
- Then get support for each person involved to be heard and understood about how they are feeling, what matters to them, and how they would like to move forward.
- Move from positions to interests and needs.
- Positions and interests are negotiable. Needs are not negotiable.
- In structural conflicts it is not always possible to meet every person’s needs. Instead, you may have to change the structure.
- Acknowledge and learn from the past, and look to the future, towards what you want to create.
- Identify and develop workable action steps.
- Make verbal or written agreements about these steps.
- Provide feedback to the community about how the system is working, so that you can adapt it for greater effectiveness when needed.
Designing conflict engagement systems based on dialogue
One way to start designing a dialogical conflict system is to ask what has worked well in the past, when we spoke with someone we felt tension with and were happy with the results. We also need to ask what has not worked so well: to explore what seems to make things more painful. And, as in designing a vision statement, we need to dream a little: to ask what our conflict system would look like if it were as we dream it could be.
When designing a conflict engagement system, make sure to involve all members of your community: everyone who will be using the system. Consider how to support those who make your system work smoothly. For example, will those who host your dialogues want any kind of compensation, inspiration or practice? Also consider where your conflict dialogues will be held, how new members will be told how the system works, and how people in the community can initiate your chosen practice.
Note that your community-wide system may also include smaller systems, as each family or household may have a different way of talking through conflict. Your school, workplace and other communities you are part of may have completely different systems. Remember that if we don’t choose a system for ourselves, we are likely to inherit the one that was set up for us by others, whether we like it or not. In any case, we often benefit most from a system that we helped create, and that we know how to adapt if conditions require it.
As you develop and improve your conflict system, you may find that things go most smoothly when it is integrated with your other systems: ways of making decisions, sharing feedback, sharing information and sharing resources.
Dominic Barter speaks on designing dialogical systems, including systems for engaging with conflict. Barter has been investigating the nature of conflict since 1995.
Many of us have been taught to see conflict as something that happens between two people, as if humans didn’t live together in communities and societies that affect us and are affected by us. In fact, all conflicts arise within a community context. This context includes historical events, the other people around us, and numerous social conditions influencing our choices.
When we experience the fire of conflict arising in the body, it is sometimes useful to consider these conditions. We can acknowledge our own agency in the situation, and also acknowledge that others are making choices too, that our choices affect each other, and that we are all acting out of thousands of years of history involving millions of people. For many of us, it is an earth-shattering moment when we realise how much impact our choices have on others. It can be a moment that is both frightening and empowering.
After considering this, when we think about whom to invite into dialogue with us, we can include those in our community who understand, or have co-created, the conditions that gave rise to the conflict. These are likely to be the same people who can work with us to create different conditions going forward: conditions that we hope will generate greater well-being. And when we talk together, we can learn what gave rise to the acts that caused pain, and we can choose new acts to repair harm, meet needs, and restore community and connection.
Types of conflict
All conflicts involve people. But interpersonal conflict is in many cases the external manifestation of something underneath. We may be projecting our own inner conflicts, acting as if others are causing them; we may be unconsciously reacting to the tense dynamic of the group field; or we may be suffering from oppressive structures of which we are unaware.
The first step in dealing with conflict is to know what is really causing it, instead of quickly blaming another person. The following table, based on Integral Theory, gives a general overview of the different types of conflict and what causes them.
| Interior | Exterior | |
|---|---|---|
| Individual | Intention: inner conflict. Strong feelings of guilt or resentment towards ourselves. Anxiety, fear and other painful feelings when exploring our own limits. Little clarity about what we really value or need. | Behaviour: interpersonal conflict. Perceiving differences as a threat to our needs. Poor communication skills. High combustibility: showing strong emotions of anger, rage or annoyance. |
| Collective | Culture: cultural conflict. A communication style reflecting cultural aggressiveness and violence. Unconscious use of prejudice, stereotypes and other violent cultural values. Binary thinking coupled with a competitive attitude: “I am right, you are wrong.” Power abuses due to differences in rank. | Systems: structural conflict (in groups). Lack of a common vision. Exhausting, divisive or unproductive meetings. Lack of crucial information. Different interpretations of verbal agreements. No processes for accountability. No membership criteria or new-member screening process. No processes to handle emotions. |
Types of conflict and their causes, arranged in the four quadrants of Integral Theory (individual and collective, interior and exterior).
Three elements to understand conflict
Just as it can be useful to understand the type of conflict, it can also help to know that most conflicts, large or small, interpersonal or international, follow much the same pattern, characterised by three important elements.
Conflict arises when we perceive a difference as a threat to getting our needs met. It is fuelled by the usually strong emotional response we give to this perception (our combustibility) and sustained by the unequal distribution of power between human beings. Difference, combustibility and power are the key elements present in every conflict.
| Element | What it means |
|---|---|
| Perceiving differences as a threat | Conflict arises when we perceive differences as a threat to what we most value, or when we believe these differences will prevent us from meeting our basic needs. |
| Combustibility | Some people make sparks fly in their interactions with others. Other people let sparks grow until they turn into a fire (big combustibility). Some people have enough control of their emotions that their sparks extinguish themselves. |
| Power abuses | The unequal distribution of power among people, and the different ways we use our own power, influence the number and nature of our conflicts. |
Conflict can be an excellent teacher. It can show us where we believe others are different from us. It can show us what is important to us: what we really care about, what truly matters. And it can reveal hidden structures of power that oppress all of us, to the extent that they prevent us from meeting collective needs. Through supported dialogue we can learn to step towards conflict and through it, learning incredibly valuable, life-changing lessons along the way.
Different attitudes towards conflict
We have an infinite number of choices when we discover that conflict has arisen. Chances are, most of us don’t have a feeling of “Hurrah! Conflict has arrived! Our relationships are being updated through the medium of pain.” Although we may aspire to this celebratory and collaborative attitude, especially when we understand what a valuable teacher conflict can be, in many situations we are more likely to avoid conflict, compete with others, accommodate others’ needs, or try to reach a compromise.
A given person may show different attitudes depending on the role they play in the conflict; a person may behave differently in a conflict with their mother, partner, a workmate or a stranger. A person may also behave differently depending on how much they care about the issue.
Neil Katz and colleagues created a model of attitudes towards conflict based on how much we value personal interests as opposed to personal relationships. For instance, a competitive approach is more oriented towards defending one’s own interests than caring for relationships, while an accommodating approach prioritises relationships over personal interests.
| Attitude | Our interests are… | The relationship is… |
|---|---|---|
| Competition | important | not very important |
| Avoidance | not very important | not very important |
| Collaboration | important | very important |
| Compromise | in between | very important |
| Accommodation | not very important | very important |
Attitudes towards conflict. Based on Katz, Neil H. and Lawyer, John W., Conflict Resolution: Building Bridges, Corwin Press, 1994.
Although we might be inclined to think of the collaborative approach as the most desirable, none of them should be idealised. The attitude or strategy we adopt in a conflict will depend on many factors that will affect our actual response.
Tools for working with conflict
Know your reflex postures. In conflict, we can be in the green zone, where we are open and welcoming, or in the red zone, where we react on reflex. Tools that help us return to the green zone include breathing, meditation, a space to release tension, and thinking through our plan B.
Some tools for working with conflict in a group:
- Restorative circles, a practice developed by Dominic Barter, who speaks in the video above.
- Reclaiming our projections (after Peter Koenig).
- Playfight: putting our bodies into play to explore conflict in a safe space.
- Emotional regulation: regular spaces, or rituals, where people can share how they feel with the group, as support for what they are going through. People share their mental load, their tensions, their current and future needs, and the resources available to overcome problems, and others help them through their difficulties. The others listen without judgement and without reacting, in service of the person sharing, putting themselves in that person’s place.
Conflict transformation and mediation
Your progress is saved in this browser. Register to save it on every device.
Text © IN.PACT partnership, shared under CC BY-SA 4.0. Images, videos and quoted works belong to their authors and are not covered by this licence unless stated.