Lesson 2 · Module 2

Participatory design and co-creation

Move from consultation to co-creation with four tools from the Grain&Sens ecovillage: listening circles, the Six Thinking Hats, consent decision-making and peer co-development.

  • ⏱ About 80 minutes
  • Contributors: Grain&Sens, Gaia Education
  • CC BY-SA 4.0

Facilitation processes in participatory design and co-creation are structured approaches that guide diverse participants, with various backgrounds and expectations, from your community through collaborative activities to co-create solutions and desired outcomes for the challenges you face. These processes emphasise equal participation, mutual learning and shared decision-making, ensuring that all voices are heard and valued.

The facilitator acts as a neutral guide, trust builder, enabler and users’ advocate. Their responsibilities include preparing inclusive environments, managing group dynamics, and ensuring participants’ needs are represented, using an array of practical tools to achieve this (for example brainstorming, prototyping, experience mapping, visioning, backcasting, scenario analysis and canvases). This should lead to emergent co-creation, democratise design, and lead to more innovative, inclusive, community-centred and sustainable outcomes.

The paradigm shift in youth participation: from consultation to co-creation

In the landscape of European youth work and Erasmus+ projects, the concept of “participation” has evolved significantly. Historically, participation often meant consultation: adults or organisations design a programme, and young people are asked to validate or consume it. While better than exclusion, this top-down approach often fails to tap into the full potential of young people. True innovation arises not from consultation, but from co-creation.

Co-creation is a collaborative process where all stakeholders (youth workers, young people, local communities and partners) act as equal designers. Projects co-created by the community they serve are more resilient, more relevant and more sustainable. They address real needs rather than perceived ones, and they foster a sense of ownership that helps the project survive beyond its initial funding period.

Understanding community systems

To co-create effectively, you must first understand the system in which you are operating. A community is not a static collection of individuals; it is a complex, adaptive system, as we saw in Topic 1. It has its own culture, power dynamics, unwritten rules and feedback loops.

When we introduce a new project into a community, we are introducing a perturbation into this system. If the design of the project ignores the existing system (its history, its fears, its strengths), the project will probably face resistance or fail. Participatory design requires deep “listening” to the system before any “solving” begins.

This topic proposes a specific framework for navigating these systems, drawn from the successful experience of the Grain&Sens ecovillage, which shows how a community can regenerate its social fabric through radical co-creation. By studying their methods, we can learn how to build “community systems” that are inclusive, innovative and participatory.

The Grain&Sens case study: a model of co-creation

The core premise of Grain&Sens is that the community holds the solution to its own problems. The role of the facilitator is not to bring the answers, but to create the container and the tools for the community to generate them. This approach relies on:

  • Radical inclusion: everyone is a resource.
  • Process over content: the way decisions are made is as important as the decisions themselves.
  • Systems thinking: viewing problems as interconnected parts of a whole.

In the following sections, we break down the four specific tools used by the Grain&Sens community that allow a group to move from chaotic discussion to structured, innovative co-creation.

Each tool comes with an exercise designed for a group. If you are learning on your own, try the exercises with a group you belong to (friends, family, colleagues or a community group), or read them through and plan how you would run them.

Tool 1: Listening at the Centre

The theory of the listening circle

The first pillar of the approach is the practice of “Listening at the Centre”, as in a sharing circle (see Module 1). This is not merely a facilitation technique; it is a philosophical stance.

In traditional meetings, listening is often passive. People listen to formulate their rebuttal, or they listen only to the person with the highest status. In the Listening at the Centre model, the act of listening becomes the central organising principle of the group. The goal is to create a “holding environment” where every voice can be heard without judgement, interruption or immediate reaction.

The “Centre” is metaphorical. It represents the shared humanity and the collective intelligence of the group. When the group focuses on the Centre, members stop seeing each other as opponents or competitors and start seeing themselves as co-inhabitants of the same space. This shift is critical for youth work, where power dynamics (adult and youth, expert and novice) often stifle innovation.

Practical implementation: the physical and virtual circle

To implement Listening at the Centre, the physical (or virtual) arrangement of the group is crucial.

Physical set-up. Participants sit in a true circle. There is no head of the table. No one stands at the front to “present”. The facilitator sits as an equal, perhaps holding a “talking piece” (an object that signifies the right to speak). The talking piece is passed around. Only the person holding the piece may speak. Others listen silently. This simple rule removes the cross-talk that often drowns out minority voices or introverted participants.

The process:

  1. Opening. The group acknowledges the purpose of the session.
  2. Round robin. Each person speaks in turn, holding the talking piece. The rule is: “Speak from your heart, not your head.” This encourages personal storytelling over abstract debate.
  3. Deep listening. Listeners are asked to suspend judgement. They are not thinking “I agree” or “I disagree.” They are thinking: “I hear you. What is this person feeling? What is their experience? How will it contribute to the problem?”
  4. Reflection. After the round, the group reflects on what was heard: “What patterns do we see? What emotions emerged? What solution could be foreseen?”

Virtual adaptation. For online collaborations, the circle must be recreated digitally. This can be done using video-conferencing tools where participants are arranged in a grid that approximates a circle. A virtual “talking piece” (a shared document or a specific chat message) can serve the same function. The facilitator must be vigilant to ensure that the mute button is used respectfully and that participants do not interrupt each other.

Why it works for youth innovation

Young people often feel unheard in adult-led structures. The Listening at the Centre tool validates their existence and their ideas. When a young person feels truly heard, their engagement shifts from passive compliance to active ownership.

Furthermore, this tool creates a “safe space” for risk-taking. Innovation requires the possibility of failure. In a circle where judgement is suspended, young people are more likely to propose “wild ideas” that might otherwise be suppressed.

At the Grain&Sens ecovillage, Listening at the Centre is often the first step in any new initiative. Before discussing what to do, the community spends time listening to each of the meeting participants or the people involved in the problem. This prevents the common pitfall of implementing a solution that does not fit the community’s actual context.

Tool 2: the Six Thinking Hats

The theory of parallel thinking

Once the group has listened and established a shared understanding, the next challenge is to generate ideas and solutions. However, groups often get stuck in argument. One person argues logically, another argues emotionally, and a third worries about risks. This “spaghetti” thinking leads to conflict and inefficiency.

Edward de Bono’s Six Thinking Hats method solves this by forcing the group to think in parallel (instead of spaghetti thinking, when all our thoughts are expressed at the same time). Instead of everyone wearing all the hats at once, the whole group puts on the same “hat” for a set period. This focuses the collective intelligence and eliminates the friction of conflicting perspectives.

The six hats explained

Hat Mode of thinking In short
White Facts Gather data to understand the issue or problem to solve.
Red Feelings State hunches and intuition without judgement or prejudice.
Black Judgement Spot difficulties and dangers; question the feasibility of approaches to the problem.
Yellow Positivity Be optimistic; probe for value and benefits.
Green Creativity Express new concepts and perceptions.
Blue Analysis Manage the process and make sure that each hat is used correctly.

Summary of a Six Thinking Hats infographic. Source: Hidden Door.

Each hat represents a specific mode of thinking. At the Grain&Sens ecovillage, the hats are used to explore a problem or idea from every angle.

1. The White Hat (facts and information)

  • Focus: neutral, objective data. What do we know? What information do we need?
  • Example at Grain&Sens: “We know there are 50 young people in the area. We know the budget is €10,000. We don’t know their interests yet.”
  • Rule: no opinions, no guesses. Only facts.

2. The Red Hat (feelings and intuition)

  • Focus: emotions, gut feelings, hunches.
  • Example at Grain&Sens: “I feel excited about this idea, but I feel anxious about the funding.” “The community feels wary of outsiders.”
  • Rule: no justification needed. “I feel this way” is a complete answer. This validates the emotional reality of young people.

3. The Black Hat (caution and critical judgement)

  • Focus: risks, difficulties, why something might fail.
  • Example at Grain&Sens: “This plan requires skills we don’t have.” “The timeline is too tight.” “This might breach the GDPR.”
  • Rule: this is not negativity; it is risk management. It protects the project from failure. It must be used constructively, not destructively.

4. The Yellow Hat (benefits and optimism)

  • Focus: value, benefits, feasibility, positive outcomes.
  • Example at Grain&Sens: “This will build strong community bonds.” “This is a low-cost solution.” “This aligns with our values.”
  • Rule: look for the best possible outcome. Find the “why” behind the idea.

5. The Green Hat (creativity and new ideas)

  • Focus: alternatives, possibilities, provocation, innovation.
  • Example at Grain&Sens: “What if we did the opposite?” “Can we use a different platform?” “Let’s brainstorm wild ideas without judging them.”
  • Rule: no criticism allowed. Quantity over quality. This is the engine of innovation.

6. The Blue Hat (process and control)

  • Focus: the “meta” thinking. Managing the process, setting the agenda, summarising, and deciding the next steps.
  • Example at Grain&Sens: “We have spent 20 minutes on the Green Hat. Now let’s move to the Yellow Hat.” “What decision do we need to make at the end of this session?”
  • Rule: usually worn by the facilitator, but can be shared. It keeps the group on track.

Applying the hats in co-creation

At Grain&Sens, the Six Hats are not used in a rigid sequence but are adapted to the needs of the moment. A typical co-creation session might look like this:

  1. Blue Hat: define the problem statement. “We need to design a summer programme for local young people.”
  2. White Hat: gather data. “Who are the young people? What are their current activities?”
  3. Red Hat: check the emotional climate. “Are they interested? Are they tired of adult-led programmes?”
  4. Green Hat: brainstorm ideas. “Let’s generate 20 ideas.”
  5. Yellow Hat: evaluate the best ideas. “Why is this idea good?”
  6. Black Hat: stress-test the top ideas. “What could go wrong with this one?”
  7. Blue Hat: decide on the next steps and assign tasks.

Other co-creation sessions are possible, depending on your problem, on how you as a facilitator sense the group, and on which sequence will be most beneficial for your group. For example, another session could look like this:

  1. White Hat (facts): think about the facts. Gather data to understand the issue or problem to solve.
  2. Yellow Hat (benefits): think about the good things, all of the benefits. Be optimistic; probe for value and benefits.
  3. Red Hat (feelings): think about feelings. Feelings can change; no reasons are given.
  4. Green Hat (creativity): think about creative ideas and possibilities. Express new concepts and perceptions.
  5. Blue Hat (analysis): plan and organise the thinking process, and make sure that each hat is used correctly.
  6. Black Hat (cautions): think about problems, concerns and difficulties. Spot the risks; logical reasons are given.

Sequence taken from a Six Thinking Hats infographic. Source: Dreamstime.

An introduction to Edward de Bono’s Six Thinking Hats.

In many youth projects, the decision-making process gets stuck in “consensus”. Consensus requires that everyone agrees with a proposal. While this sounds ideal, it often leads to:

  • Decision paralysis: the group cannot move forward because one person has a minor objection.
  • Watered-down solutions: the final decision is the lowest common denominator that everyone can tolerate, rather than the best solution.
  • Hidden dissent: people say “I agree” but do not support the decision, leading to poor implementation.

At the Grain&Sens ecovillage, consent-based decision-making, rooted in sociocracy, is put into action.

Consensus and consent:

  • Consensus: “Everyone agrees.” (No objections allowed.)
  • Consent: “No one has a major objection.” (Reasonable objections are welcome, but minor concerns are not enough to block.)

In consent, the question is not “Do you like this?” but “Can you live with this?” If a proposal is safe enough to try and good enough to proceed, it is adopted.

The process is structured to ensure that objections are heard and integrated, but not used to block progress indefinitely.

  1. The proposal. A clear, actionable proposal is presented (for example: “We will launch the pilot project in June with a budget of €5,000”).
  2. Clarification round. Participants ask questions to understand the proposal. No opinions yet.
  3. Amendment round. Participants suggest improvements. The proposal is modified to incorporate good suggestions.
  4. Objection round. Participants are asked: “Do you have a reasoned, major objection?”
    • Reasoned: based on facts or values, not just “I don’t like it.”
    • Major: the objection must be to the process or the outcome, in a way that would cause harm or violate the organisation’s goals.
  5. Integration. If an objection is raised, the group works to modify the proposal to address it.
  6. Final consent check. “Does anyone still have a major objection?”
    • If no: the decision is made.
    • If yes: the group either modifies the proposal again or refers it to a higher authority (if one exists).

The Université du Nous describes the same process in a slightly different set of steps, with a round for feedback before amendments:

Step What happens Who speaks
0. Prepare the proposal Group members share their views and ideas. One person prepares a reasoned proposal, and the proposal owner presents it. Everyone in turn, in a circle; then the proposal owner
1. Clarify “Have I understood the proposal correctly?” Open: anyone may ask
2. Feedback “What impressions and feelings can I share with the group and the proposal owner, to contribute to step 3?” Everyone in turn, in a circle
3. Amendments The proposal owner can clarify, amend or withdraw the proposal. A withdrawn proposal goes back to step 0. The proposal owner
4. Objections “What would either not respect my limits, or put our organisation or project in danger?” Everyone in turn, in as many rounds as needed
5. Improve Work together to resolve each objection, one after the other. When each objection is withdrawn, the facilitator goes back to step 4 to check that there are no new objections. Open; guided by the facilitator
Celebrate If there are no new objections, celebrate the decision. Everyone

Based on the “Consent decision making” process diagram by the Université du Nous, licensed CC BY-SA.

Why it works for youth innovation

Consent is a powerful tool for young people because it respects their agency without requiring unanimity. It acknowledges that young people are capable of making difficult decisions and that disagreement is a sign of engagement, not failure.

At the Grain&Sens ecovillage, this approach ensures that the project moves forward even in the face of diverse opinions. It also prevents the “tyranny of the majority” or the “tyranny of the loudest voice”.

  • Treating objections as a veto. Remember, an objection must be “major”. A preference is not an objection.
  • Lack of clarity. Proposals must be specific enough to be evaluated.
  • Fear of conflict. Facilitators must create a safe space where objections are welcomed, not punished.

Tool 4: peer co-development

The concept of co-development

While the previous tools focus on group decision-making and design, peer co-development focuses on the growth of the individuals within the group. Co-development is not just about learning skills; it is about mutual support and shared responsibility for growth.

Co-development is a structured process where peers help each other solve problems, reflect on their practice, and develop their leadership capacities. It shifts the role of the “expert” from the facilitator to the peer group.

Key techniques of peer co-development

There are several techniques used in the Grain&Sens framework to facilitate co-development.

1. The co-development cycle

  • Step 1, the case presentation: one member presents a real challenge they are facing (for example “I am struggling to engage the quiet students in my group”).
  • Step 2, clarification: the group asks clarifying questions to understand the context. No advice yet.
  • Step 3, reflection and feedback: the group offers insights, perspectives and possible solutions. They act as a mirror, helping the presenter see blind spots.
  • Step 4, action planning: the presenter decides on a concrete action plan based on the feedback.
  • Step 5, follow-up: in the next session, the presenter reports back on the results.

2. Check-in and check-out

  • Check-in: at the start of a session, each person shares their current state of mind. This builds empathy and helps the group adjust the pace.
  • Check-out: at the end, each person shares what they learned or how they feel. This ensures closure and reinforces learning.

3. The “feedback sandwich”

Instead of the traditional “praise, critique, praise”, the approach uses an “observation, impact, suggestion” model:

  • Observation: “I noticed that in the last meeting, you interrupted the young person.”
  • Impact: “This made them stop speaking and look down.”
  • Suggestion: “Next time, try to wait 3 seconds after they finish before speaking.”

Synthesis: integrating the tools

The four tools discussed (Listening at the Centre, the Six Thinking Hats, consent-based decision-making and peer co-development) are not isolated techniques. They form an ecosystem.

  • Listening creates the foundation of trust and safety.
  • The Six Hats provide the structure for creative and critical thinking.
  • Consent ensures that decisions are made efficiently and inclusively.
  • Co-development ensures that the people involved grow and sustain the process.

When applied together, they create a robust framework for participatory design that is adaptable to any context, from a local youth centre to a small community.

The future of youth work lies in the ability to co-create with young people, not just for them. These tools (listening, the Six Hats, consent and co-development) provide a practical, proven framework for achieving this. They are a selection of tools for regenerative community that you can adapt for your own group or community.

Participatory design and co-creation

Your progress is saved in this browser. Register to save it on every device.

Text © IN.PACT partnership, shared under CC BY-SA 4.0. Images, videos and quoted works belong to their authors and are not covered by this licence unless stated.

Partners